Now That’s What I Call A Major Flop

Down Is The New Up

40 Backstreet Boys Never Gone (2005): -77,6%

Well, although the Backstreet Boys claimed that they were Never Gone, for the general public they definitely were. This reunion attempt was a massive flop. Their 2000 album Black & Blue sold 13,34 million EAS thanks to the massive hysteria surrounding the group. In reality, it was already a disappointment with sales down 55% from Millennium. In spite of these negative signs, they tried it still again with Never Gone and remained below 3 million EAS.

39 Dire Straits On Every Street (1991): -77,8%

The second highest selling album in absolute terms of this ranking. On Every Street moved a huge 10,15 million EAS through the years. While this is a high figure, it pales in comparison of Brothers In Arms. The 1985 blockbuster sold 45,75 million EAS to date. Ironically, On Every Street seemed truly strong upon release thanks to the anticipation effect, but it is now clear that if it wasn’t for Dire Straits‘ popularity back then, it would have sold nowhere near 10 million up to date.

38 Gorillaz Plastic Beach (2010): -78%

After two smash albums, one may expect great results from the third output. Gorillaz‘ self-titled debut sold 8,03 million EAS, their sophomore album Demon Days did 9,67 million. Still, their 2010 comeback Plastic Beach sold only 2,13 million units in total. The lack of hits always hurts no matter who you are and how high you are rated.

37 Christina Aguilera Bionic (2010): -78,1%

Often used as the ultimate example of a bomb on online boards, Aguilera‘s Bionic charts at #37 on our list of the biggest freefalls studied so far. It sold a mere 1,38 million EAS, a far cry from Back to Basics‘ tally of 6,30 million. That latter album already sold only half of its predecessor, pushing fans to hope for a rebound with Bionic. Its final results ended up being all the more disappointing.

36 Usher Here I Stand (2008): -78,3%

When Here I Stand was announced, it was regarded as one of the most anticipated albums in recent years. It was natural since Confessions was the lone Diamond album in the US in like a century and its singles topped the Hot 100 chart for 28 weeks. Usher was so big during this era that many took as a given that he was the Michael Jackson of the 00s. All told, Confessions recorded 19,82 million EAS. Here I Stand did nearly 5 times less at 4,31 million. Lessons learned: it’s never a given to be successful.

35 Jackson 5 Moving Violation (1975): -78,3%

During the first half of the 70s, the Jackson 5 tried to maintain as long as possible the initial hype they created with their various early #1 singles. By 1973, the group wasn’t a selling force anymore with both Skywriter and Get It Together generating an average of less than 700,000 EAS. The 1974 rebound Dancing Machine, which sold 1,68 million EAS, got them hoping for better days. At a disastrous 364,000 EAS, Moving Violation completely killed this new momentum. This flop caused the departure of the Jackson 5 from Motown. The newly named Jacksons would sign with Epic immediately after this bomb.

34 Pink Floyd The Endless River (2014): -78,4%

Possibly the most atypical release of this list. The Endless River could be seen as a bootleg release. After all, it is made of recordings from The Division Bell sessions. It is also almost entirely an instrumental LP. At the other end, it was promoted as the first album of the band in 20 years and their final studio output. It started strong and sold well in the Christmas season. Nevertheless, it sold 2,85 million EAS, a tiny fraction of The Division Bell‘s 13,19 million total.

33 Bruce Springsteen Tunnel of Love (1987): -79%

It’s the dark side of success. Tunnel of Love was a #1 album in various countries. Overall, it moved close to 10 million EAS. We can’t forget it was the follow up of Born in the USA though. This album is on 47,37 million so far, so falling to 10 million is still a massive decline. After that, Springsteen continued to release multi-million selling records, without ever coming close again of his 1984 peak. Basically, Tunnel of Love had the bad luck to follow an album that was even bigger than its artist.

32 AC/DC For Those About to Rock We Salute You (1981): -79,5%

Here comes the highest selling album of this top 50. For Those About to Rock We Salute You sold a solid 11,93 million and keeps on selling well. The point is, AC/DC is a massive selling band. Their previous album Back In Black sold an unreal 58,22 million EAS. One may say the comparison is unfair for For Those…, but then The Razors Edge released in 1990 did 17,67 million. This shows that AC/DC have it and that the 1981 LP simply missed to produce enough iconic tracks by their standards.

31 Usher Hard II Love (2016): -81,7%

Hard to love indeed. Usher had rebounded after his 2008 troubles. In 2010, Raymond v. Raymond sold 6,92 million EAS. It was his last whisper as a popular star though. Looking 4 Myself from 2012 did 2,28 million, a 67% drop. Then, Hard II Love was an immense disaster. It sold 418,000 units in total. Hard to believe from someone who was expected to debut with 1 million pure US sales a few years before.

4 7 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

34 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
James Hall

From a statistical data standpoint this article has merit. Although many factors can be attributed to low sales.
I think it would be interesting to compare high selling “junk” to low selling artistic achievement(s).

Lydia

Whoa, Paul Simon’s career was definitely not “mostly done” by 1997, the albums Surprise (2006) and So Beautiful or So What (2011) are both incredible

Simon B.

AC/DC’s For Those About to Rock should have sold many more copies. The problem was not that it “missed to produce enough iconic tracks by their standards” but that in the US, the band’s label released the five-year-old Dirty Deeds Done Dirt Cheap just months before the new album, its second with new singer Brian Johnson, was supposed to come out. Dirty Deeds went on to sell massive numbers, robbing momentum from the superb For Those About to Rock, and causing the band to suffer from overexposure by the time it came out. Dirty Deeds is a great album, but… Read more »

Matrix

If an CSPC analysis for ‘Grease 2’ soundtrack would be done, I have no doubt that album would have take the first place on this list. Consider the possible difference between ‘Grease 1’ soundtrack – 52 216 000 milion CSPC – and big flop named ‘Grease 2’ sounftrack.

Matrix

Some more candidates for this Flop – list:

The Rolling Stones: ‘Tattoo You* 16.24 million units ——–>’Undercover’ 3.93 million.

Bon Jovi: ‘Crush’ 12.13 million units ——–>’Bounce’ 3.15 nillion.

Matrix

Looked through Rod Stewart CSPC numbers, and noticed several strong candidates for this list. For example ‘Every Picture Tells a Story’ had registered 30,37 million sales. Album after that *Never A Dull Moment* produced ‘only’ 5.64 million.

Or, ‘Blondes Have More Fun’ 15.22 million, compared to the following album ‘Foolish Behaviour’ just 3.68 million units.

And, last but not least, ‘Vagabound Heart’ produced 11. 28 million units. But, next album ‘A Spanner In the Works’ flops hard, just only 1.98 million units!

34
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x