Forum
Ok i got it. The 3 million copies from this absurd article came from Venus, where Gaga performed in 2013, lol.
Did Jay Z also buy this site to lie and cheat in favor of his wife? Already enough Forbes, Pitchfork, and all the means of communication that he can manipulate in favor of his beloved...
Joking Jay z =), don't send me yours private assassins for shut my mouth up.
Basically ignoring all the facts once again. If you have valid data to put there, you are welcome. If you want to continue with wild fanatism, ATRL will be a better place for you.
Sure, but we're at a beystan site. Everything here is cover-up like her career.
He demeans Gaga, Britney, Rihanna and others and never disfavors his fave. Is this the way he wants to pass credibility to the audience here? If you're going to do something, do it right, be impartial and honest.
This was suposed to be a creditable site for any artist, not a Beyoncé stanpage.
I'll come back when the mistakes are fixed, taking advantage of, add the new sales of Rihanna, Gaga and others in Germany, which were added recently. Thank u.
You did not say anything to me, you did not answer me. It did not prove right and I was wrong, just like any Beyoncé fan is. And if the ATRL has the least notion and partiality that does not exist here, I'd rather stay right there. Bye beystan.
You've given her nearly 30 million singles since the last update of this article. Why not put 200 million singles at once? The clowning was already embarrassing.
I'm quitting this site.
More blabla, still 0 evidence. Why don't you talk about the facts?
You claim Irreplaceable sold 160k in Oceania up to date. Let's check the facts from Australia:
YEC 2006
23 - Irreplaceable
35 - My Love (by JT)
YEC 2007
42 - Irreplaceable
61 - My Love (by JT)
Both tracks debuted in Nov 2006, both dropped out in May 2007. They were much closer in YECs of physical singles, which were already minor by then, so the gap in YECs is due to downloads. Yet...
Justin Timberlake My Love SME 2x PLATINUM 2008
Oops. Facts prove Irreplaceable was already easily eligible for 2xP 10 years ago. With 140k for My Love, Irr had already sold 170/180k by then. Since mid-2008, the track added well over 50% of sales in both the US and the UK so there is absolutely no reason to assume it hasn't done the same in Oz. We are already looking for 250k sales in Oz. It shouldn't come as a surprise for you since you speak about Rihanna, which went 2xP with Shut Up And Drive in spite of charting lower than Irr in 2007 YEC and having obviously no sale in 2006. Of course, this figure of 250k+ includes physicals in Oz, which amount for 40k as per YECs (I can prove it too if you want).
Wait, we haven't even talk about ringtones. They represented 25% of Oz digital value in 2007 against 49% for downloads, so nearly half. Even if we assume it sold RTs only in its first 2 years, that's 140 (its DLs) * 0,5 (share in value) / 2,5 (gap of price DLs vs RTs) * 1,5 (the factor for urban songs which over-perform ringtones) = 42k ringtones calculated. All in all, we are comfortably at 250k digital units in Australia alone. In NZ, the market was at 11% of Oz, so even assuming the track performed 30% weaker than there, that's still nearly 20k to date.
The only real assumption is that it added 50% since mid-2008, fact is it doubled or more its sales in the UK. Since Australia market grew way more post-2007 than both the US and the UK, it is very, very conservative to stick to that 50%, which still pushes us to 275k sales in Oceania.
Can you tell me now your educated arguments that bring you to 160k there? Or is it just a number thrown out of your mind?
then leave already and quit arguing, your obsessive hatred of Beyoncé is showing (typical Navy/Brit Army/Little Monster)
I'm leaving because of all of these lies, it's so much for me. If you want to stay here to being comfortable about all Beyoncé's lies, you're welcome, i'm not. =)
PS: Get ready Michael Jackson, Bey is coming for your head when she reach 300mi records sold by 2020 in this nonsense site despite being selling 5m records per era (and decreasing, even with using black people and other excluded niches for sell her bad stuff)
You are leaving because once confronted to your fanciful 'estimations' like 160k in Oceania, you have 0 argument to back you up. I repeat that if you want to discuss figures feel free, but your upcoming trolling / insults will be moved to trash.
MJD is far far away to be a bey stan haha. I already confronted him because of some negative coments about Beyoncé. How I had predicted Bey is very undercertified in a lot of countries. Columbia seems doesn't care to update her catalog and makes she looks sell less than she does.
It's pointless trying to explain things to Beyoncé haters. Alot of them has grounded in their minds that shes a local flop outside of America
How is her selling ability overrated? 74M EAS accumulated over 6 albums is very impressive, that's only 12M behind Rihanna and 26M behind Britney despite having 2&3 fewer albums released in much worse selling conditions. Britney's first 6 albums were released from 1999-2007 (two of which were during peak selling years) while Rihanna's first 6 albums were released from 2005-2011. Meanwhile, it took Beyoncé 13 years, a much greater difference. Had Lemonade been her 8th studio album, she'd very likely be on about 90-95M.
Exactly. Beyoncé could release albums and singles year after year and enjoyed much more her sales peek as britney and rihanna did. Probably she would be very close to Britney or outsold her.
Teca, please do leave and never post on this site. You are unwanted here. And you are wrong.
