Starting her career so strongly, the popularity of Lady Gaga inevitably began to diminish album by album. As the years passed by, that’s exactly how her career was being painted but then out of the blue, the singer decide to change her landscape and ended up proving a lot of people wrong.
On a downward trajectory for many years, her career was reinvigorated when she starred and sang in the Box Office smash, A Star Is Born OST.
But has she managed to solidify this revival in fortune, with her lastest pop effort, Chromatica?
Before we answer that or get there, let’s jump back in time to the very beginning of her career.
It’s 2008 and Just Dance is starting to gain heavy rotation, but essentially, it is just another dance hit, by some unknown singer.
It’s 2009 and Lady Gaga is the hottest popstar on the planet. The impact she has had from nothing, to such success and popularity, in such a short time, is phenomenal and illustrates just how deeply she managed to crossover into the mainstream.
Up until the Born This Way single, everything she had released was an out of this world smash. Judas, broke this trend completely and suddenly getting a hit, seemed to become more difficult, with each subsequent release.
In 2017 and in spite of her career having been in steady decline, she was still a very recognisable star, whose public image, had undergone a definite improvement. Positive comments, for once, were starting to outweigh the usually far greater in number, disparaging and negative ones.
So, what a perfect time for a career up turn and that is exactly what happened, with the #1 hit single, Shallow. Her name was everywhere again in 2020 and for the right reasons, thanks to songs like Stupid Love and Rain On Me.
As usual, I’ll be using the Commensurate Sales to Popularity Concept in order to relevantly gauge her results.
This concept will not only bring you sales information for all Lady Gaga‘s albums, physical and download singles, as well as audio and video streaming, but it will also determine their true popularity.
If you are not yet familiar with the CSPC method, the next page explains it with a short video. I fully recommend watching the video before getting into the sales figures. Of course, if you are a regular visitor feel free to skip the video and get into the figures.
The Commensurate Sales to Popularity Concept (CSPC)
There are two ways to understand this revolutionary concept. The first is the Scribe video posted below. If you are unaware of the CSPC method, you will get the full idea within just a few minutes.
If you are a mathematical person, and want to know the full method as well as formulas, you can read the full introduction article.
Now let’s get into the artist’s sales figures in detail in order to apply this concept and define the act’s true popularity!
Lady Gaga Albums Sales
Original Album Sales – Comments
Starting with a monster seller as big as The Fame can be hard to follow up.
At 15.75 million, without counting both successful side albums The Fame Monster EP and The Remix, Lady Gaga has set the criteria for success, insanely high.
Therefore, even a great success in our day and age, like Born This Way looks someway disappointing, despite 6.73 million albums sold.
If Tony Bennett-paired Jazz album Cheek To Cheek had obvious reasons to sell in lower amounts, Artpop had none and its 2.14 million sales, pale in comparison to her debut album, yet released, only a few years earlier.
With Joanne, optimistic people will say that it stopped the decreasing trend, while pessimistic ones, will point out, it failed to regain her old fans. It sold 1.3 million pure units to date.
A Star Is Born is a flashy return to form, with 3.26 million sales so far, an outstanding figure in this format by 2018/2019 standards.
2020 output Chromatica hasn’t been defying market dynamics with sales coming mostly from fans preorders, something that is the norm nowadays. It is up to 680,000 units.
A total of 31.22 million studio albums, after 6 releases, is a very good figure, especially considering, all her ups and downs.
Lady Gaga Songs Sales
Physical Singles Sales
As a reminder, the weighting is done with a 10 to 3 ratio between one album and one physical single.
Lady Gaga is yet another artist, who emerged when physical sales were already dead.
Still, most of her singles were issued in various countries, even in the US, with many fans building their collection.
Combining this situation, with decent sales in France and Germany, brings her over 470,000 equivalent album sales from physical singles sales.
Digital Songs
As a reminder, the weighting is done with a 10 to 1,5 ratio between one album and one digital single.
As we review the most successful artists of our digital era, we have studied several acts with more than 100 million downloads sold. At more than 129 million, Lady Gaga is one of them.
The most striking illustration of the huge weight The Fame owns over her catalog, can be seen with its 80 million tracks sold, an unmatchable total.
Everything from this record turned into gold, including its deep cuts that sold incredibly well. We do not even need to mention how big Poker Face, Just Dance and Bad Romance have been. The former is one of the highest selling digital titles of all-time at 20.1 million.
Born This Way hits started strong too but slowed down much faster than singles from previous album. There are still 4 singles, at 3 million sales and more inside this LP.
In the same way, Artpops first two singles did OK-ish but subsequent extracts bombed so much, that I’m putting them among the Remaining Tracks category.
About the Joanne era, the lead single Perfect Illusion failed to gain traction but its follow up Million Reasons did well enough by 2016 standards, at 1.72 million units sold.
Songs from A Star Is Born are even greater sellers once we consider the context. Both ringtones and downloads are now close to their death, yet Shallow posts an incredible 2.55 million sales.
Both Stupid Love and Rain On Me are good sellers among 2020 songs, but the market is so weak at the moment, that it’s only good enough for 700,000 units.
Streaming
Streaming is made up of audio and video streams. Our CSPC methodology includes both to better reflect the real popularity of each track. The main source of data for each avenue is respectively Spotify and YouTube. To factor in the growing impact of multiple Asian countries where these platforms aren’t always the go-to site for music streaming, more sources have been added.
In order to account for their real popularity in each relevant country, the below sources have been used along with the mentioned ratios that reflect the market share of each area.
Audio Streams
– South Korea : Genie streams * 3.05 (consistent with Gaon streaming numbers)
– Japan : AWA streams * 100/5.5 (AWA has 5.5% of the Japanese streaming market)
– Elsewhere : Spotify streams * (370 – 8.5 – 9.5 – 33 – 9) / 207 (370 million global subscribers minus 8.5 million from South Korea minus 9.5 million from Japan minus 33 million from China divided by the number of Spotify only users minus 9 million more Asian users) + Genie streams * 3.05 (uses Genie rather than Spotify to extrapolate markets like Taiwan, Thailand and Vietnam)
Video Streams
– China* : Xiami streams * 125/6.5 (Xiami has just over 5% of the Chinese streaming market)
– Elsewhere : Youtube views
*since 96.4% of Chinese streaming platforms are free users, that paid-for users pay less than $2 a month and that they are also used as video streaming platforms, their streams are weighted in par with YouTube streams.
Audio Stream value – 1500 plays equal 1 album unit
Video Stream value – 11,750 views equal 1 album unit
Equivalent Albums Sales (EAS) = ( Spotify * 310/207 + Genie * 3.05*2 + AWA * 100/5.5 ) / 1500 + ( Xiami * 125/6.5 + YouTube ) / 11750
Top Hits
Considering how many years later streaming exploded, it is pretty insane to see Paparazzi barely 6th among the biggest songs from The Fame, in spite of a massive 209 million plays on Spotify and 475 million on YouTube
Bad Romance, Poker Face, Telephone, and Just Dance are all absolutely huge, with an average of 537,000 EAS apiece. The album stands at 3.3 million and keeps rising very fast.
Born This Way songs are undoubtedly on a lower scale but it still lands 3 songs in her top 20, most notably the title track at 339,000 EAS. It’s an increase of 101,000 units in 16 months since our last update.
Applause leads tracks from Artpop while the now controversial Do What U Want is quickly vanishing from her top songs.
Impressively, Million Reasons climbed all the way to #5 among her top streaming hits. Of course, the market was healthier, but with the strong ongoing streams of her catalog hits, plus its own soft start, it was hard to expect such a nice conclusion.
As many as 4 songs from A Star Is Born joined this top 20, with Shallow dominating. The track records more than 1.3 billion streams on Spotify, 2 billion on YouTube and large numbers in Asian platforms as well, good for 1.56 million EAS.
There are 3 songs from Chromatica which sneaked in the ranking as well, led by Rain On Me at 542,000 EAS, the 6th largest streaming hit of the singer, a ranking that is poised to improve soon.
A Star Is Born has now moved ahead of The Fame‘s total as it stands at 3,747,000 EAS, it gained 1.4 million since August 2019.
Full catalog breakdown
If you are familiar with the artist’s catalog and want to check details of each and every song, you can access to all of them right here.
Keep yourself up to date
Our website provides you a fantastic tool which fetchs updated Spotify streams as you request them, use it to watch these results grow day after day!
Lady Gaga compilations sales
It sounds fairly logical to add together weighted sales of one era – studio album, physical singles, downloads, streams – to get the full picture of an album’s popularity. For older releases though, they also generate sales of various live, music videos and compilation albums.
All those packaging-only records do not create value, they exploit the value originating from the parent studio album of each of its tracks instead. Inevitably, when such compilations are issued, this downgrades catalog sales of the original LP.
Thus, to perfectly gauge the worth of these releases, we need to re-assign sales proportionally to its contribution of all the compilations which feature its songs. The following table explains this method.
The distribution process
How to understand this table? If you check this example of Monster Ball Tour Live, those figures mean it sold 550,000 units worldwide. The second statistics column means all versions of all the songs included on this package add for 3,612,363 equivalent album sales from streams of all types.
The second part at the right of the table shows how many streams are coming from each original album plus the share it represents on the overall package streams. Thus, streaming figures tell us The Fame songs are responsible for 87% of the Monster Ball Tour Live tracklist attractiveness, which means it generated 479,000 album sales. We then apply this concept to all compilations, live albums, music videos and EPs.
Compilations sales figures listing
Most of these releases are themed around her first era, including the top two sellers, one more sign of the terrific success of The Fame.
As a bonus, below is the breakdown of the million sellers.
Total Album (all types) Sales per Country
Lady Gaga Career CSPC Results
So, after checking all the figures, how many overall equivalent album sales has each album by Lady Gaga achieved? Well, at this point we hardly need to add up all of the figures defined in this article!
In the following results table, all categories display figures in equivalent album sales. If different, pure sales are listed between parentheses.
| # | Cover | Album | Total CSPC | Sales* | Streams | Total CSPC | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Studio Albums | Other LPs | Physical Singles | Digital Singles | Last verified | Auto update | Daily Increase | |||||
| 1 |  | The Fame / The Fame Monster | 36,562,000 | 15,745,000 | 4,141,000 | 354,000(1,180,000) | 12,039,000(80,260,000) | 3,318,000 (12/22/20) | 4,283,000 (11/29/21) | Av.: 2,820LD: 2,560 | 36,562,000 |
| 2 |  | Born This Way | 12,971,000 | 6,725,000 | 468,000 | 87,000(290,000) | 4,224,000(28,160,000) | 1,132,000 (12/22/20) | 1,467,000 (11/29/21) | Av.: 980LD: 790 | 12,971,000 |
| 3 |  | Artpop | 4,454,000 | 2,135,000 | 20,000 | 21,000(70,000) | 1,236,000(8,240,000) | 879,000 (12/22/20) | 1,042,000 (11/29/21) | Av.: 480LD: 430 | 4,454,000 |
| 4 |  | Cheek To Cheek | 1,767,000 | 1,375,000 | 158,000 | 0(0) | 92,000(610,000) | 123,000 (12/22/20) | 142,000 (11/29/21) | Av.: 60LD: 70 | 1,767,000 |
| 5 |  | Joanne | 3,147,000 | 1,300,000 | 0 | 0(0) | 359,000(2,390,000) | 1,319,000 (12/22/20) | 1,488,000 (11/29/21) | Av.: 500LD: 490 | 3,147,000 |
| 6 |  | A Star Is Born | 8,514,000 | 3,255,000 | 0 | 0(0) | 707,000(4,710,000) | 3,747,000 (12/22/20) | 4,552,000 (11/29/21) | Av.: 2,350LD: 2,100 | 8,514,000 |
| 7 |  | Chromatica | 2,919,000 | 680,000 | 0 | 7,000(20,000) | 119,000(790,000) | 1,445,000 (12/22/20) | 2,114,000 (11/29/21) | Av.: 1,960LD: 1,140 | 2,919,000 |
| 8 | Orphan | 1,114,000 | 0 | 3,000 | 3,000(10,000) | 555,000(3,700,000) | 553,000 (12/22/20) | N/A | N/A | 1,114,000 | |
| *Pure sales figures updated on 12/22/20. 'Av.' stands for Average, 'LD' for Last Day. | |||||||||||
As a reminder:
- Studio Album: sales of the original album
- Other Releases: sales of compilations generated thanks to the album
- Physical Singles: sales of physical singles from the album (ratio 3/10)
- Download Singles: sales of digital singles from the album (ratio 1,5/10)
- Streaming: equivalent album sales of all the album tracks (ratio 1/1500 for Audio stream and 1/11750 for Video stream)
See where the artist ranks among remaining singers
This is it! The Fame / The Fame Monster achieves the massive total of 35.6 million equivalent album sales, way higher than anything released since 2000, by anyone minus Adele.
Incredibly, this era leads all five format categories but one. The other releases section in particular means a lot.
In fact, as Lady Gaga‘s debut album was hugely successful, we notice how many side albums got milked during this era.
A Polar opposite, Artpop bombed so badly, that her label quickly moved to something else, as there was nothing to exploit, in any profitable way.
When we first studied the diva’s discography, The Fame was responsible for more than 65% of her sales, which was worrying for her future.
A Star Is Born is changing the story though. At 7.7 million, it gives more consistency to her results. The share of her debut is still huge, but down to 52.0% at the moment.
Born This Way is a very successful album as well with over 12.6 million EAS plus solid ongoing streams.
At 2.25 million, results of Chromatica are mixed. They prove that Lady Gaga is still very relevant, more than a decade into her career, but the album failed to produce any truly big hits. It will keep climbing though.
That career total of Lady Gaga is up to 68.3 million equivalent album sales.
This total is up by 5.7 million since our last review on August 2019 and up by 14.0 million March 2018.
Singles CSPC results
The list is compiled in album equivalent sales generated by each song. Therefore, these figures are not merged units of singles formats. Instead, it includes weighted sales of the song’s physical single, download, ringtone and streaming as well as its share among sales of all albums on which it is featured.
1. 2008 – Lady Gaga – Poker Face [The Fame / The Fame Monster] – 7,140,000
2. 2009 – Lady Gaga – Bad Romance [The Fame / The Fame Monster] – 7,100,000
3. 2009 – Lady Gaga ft. Beyoncé – Telephone [The Fame / The Fame Monster] – 4,880,000
4. 2008 – Lady Gaga ft. Colby O’Donis – Just Dance [The Fame / The Fame Monster] – 4,710,000
5. 2011 – Lady Gaga – Born This Way [Born This Way] – 4,120,000
6. 2018 – Lady Gaga & Bradley Cooper – Shallow [A Star Is Born] – 3,310,000
7. 2009 – Lady Gaga – Alejandro [The Fame / The Fame Monster] – 3,010,000
8. 2008 – Lady Gaga – Paparazzi [The Fame / The Fame Monster] – 2,770,000
9. 2011 – Lady Gaga – The Edge Of Glory [Born This Way] – 2,220,000
10. 2013 – Lady Gaga – Applause [Artpop] – 1,860,000
11. 2011 – Lady Gaga – Judas [Born This Way] – 1,730,000
12. 2008 – Lady Gaga – LoveGame [The Fame / The Fame Monster] – 1,640,000
13. 2011 – Lady Gaga – Yoü And I [Born This Way] – 1,510,000
14. 2016 – Lady Gaga – Million Reasons [Joanne] – 1,400,000
If you feel inspired by this list, we just created this CSPC Lady Gaga playlist on Spotify!
Discography results
Thanks to our new ASR (Artist Success Rating) concept, we know that her sales represent 23.04 million times the purchase of her entire discography. Coupled with her total sales, it translates into an ASR score of 225.
She is just below Coldplay but ahead of Rihanna.
Records & Achievements
- At 35,603,000 EAS, The Fame / The Fame Monster is the most successful album of the 2000s.
- At 12,635,000 EAS, Born This Way is the 4th most successful album from 2011.
- At 7,140,000 EAS, Poker Face is the 2nd most successful song from 2008.
- At 7,100,000 EAS, Bad Romance is the most successful song from 2009.
- At 1,265,000 pure album sales, The Fame / The Fame Monster (inc. EP) is the last million selling international album in Japan.
- At 80,260,000 downloads and ringtones, the era The Fame / The Fame Monster is the biggest ever in terms of digital singles sales.
- At 20,110,000 downloads and ringtones, the single Poker Face is among the 10 highest selling digital single of all-time.
- At 150 weeks in 2009, Lady Gaga broke the record for most weeks charted inside the UK Single Chart during a calendar year. She also led 2010 with 123 weeks.
- At 10 weeks, Shallow is the longest running #1 hit in US Digital Song Sales chart for a female artist.
- At 24 weeks, Shallow is the longest running #1 hit in Canadian Digital Song Sales chart. It holds the same record in France at 22 weeks.
NB: EAS means Equivalent Album Sales.
You may be interested in…
… best-selling artists, albums, and singles
To improve your navigation we created several amazing cross-artists lists posted inside the CSPC: Data Collector article. Click on it to see the full listing of all CSPC results compiled so far!
… similar artists
To put figures from this article into perspective, click on the images below to reach career breakdowns of similar artists:
As usual, feel free to comment and / or ask a question!
Sources: IFPI, Spotify, YouTube, Discogs.
What are her ringtone sales by song in the US?
Also, I did the same question in Adele’s and Taylor’s Popularity Analysis. Can you answer me in their respective CSPC articles?
Hi JRVV!
Please find below her estimated / calculated ringtones singles in the US:
1 Poker Face 1425k
2 Just Dance 1375k
3 Bad Romance 900k
4 Telephone 600k
5 Paparazzi 500k
Then sales go down very quickly since later eras arrived when RTs were dead. There is LoveGame and Alejandro which did 550k combined and the rest is at most at 150k (Born This Way’s figure).
wow, her career decline is truly massive. From 33m to 2.2m. In just 8 years. Unbelievable!! That has to be the worst decline Ive seen for a major pop artist in the past 20 years. I expected better from Joanne but the era was a total non factor outside North America tho, the way she completely lost her global power is amusing. I dont know why people call it a comeback from Artpop when it did worse in every aspect except Spotify. Album sales down by almost 1 million, single sales down by several millions, YouTube views also down and… Read more »
don’t listen to obsessed haters as well. . .
thanks MJD for wonderful job.
Pobre enfermito…
So that’s it? You got no valid argument anymore so you come with insults to someone who argued (nicely) something you don’t like? Well done. There is no room for this kind of childish behaviour. I hate moving messages to trash since to me everyone is entitled to an opinion, but if this is your way to go I’ll start doing it for your messages.
Hey! I have two questions: first one, did you forget to add “Eh, Eh” to the Digital Singles page? I feel like it sold more than the album tracks on the list. Also the 15M for “The Fame” include sales from “The Fame Monster” correct? So why add those sales again in “Other releases”?
Thanks!
Hi Manuel! No figure is explicitely mentioned for Eh, Eh because I have no Soundscan figure for it, so not enough data to commit in a figure that will then be used as a receipt by other people. To be fully transparent, it comes with 630k sales in my Excel spreadsheet which includes 125k from France + Oz + estimates for remaining markets as per its streaming (both Spotify and YouTube) figures to establish its popularity. Yes, the figure of The Fame includes The Fame Monster double disc. The one which appears under the section Other releases is the stand-alone… Read more »
On page 4 you have The Fame sales at 15,920,000 but then on the overall albums sales comments you have it at 15,820,000. The studio albums sales (without EPs or Remix Albums) add 27,290,000, which should be rounded to 27.3, not 27.2, as you posted. Funny thing is I’m looking now at your previous Gaga analysis from 2016 and you have downgraded basically all her figures… despite the SuperBowl boost for her catalog. Not only they’re not up but they’re down! Lol. The Fame was at 16.2 in 2016 according to you and now it’s at 15.92… The Remix was… Read more »
The typo on TF has been fixed. Studio albums add for 27,19m. It isn’t funny but expected by everyone following sales figures. In recent times, we learned a lot of things including the (faster than elsewhere) collapse of Asian markets as well as eastern Europe markets. Basically, every small market on which it was possible to sell decently 20 years ago is now almost fully relying in streaming since majors do not invest money anymore on them. In the same way, Scandinavian figures have been adjusted since they too have been almost exclusively streaming for several years now. Everything has… Read more »
What does it have to do the Asian markets collapsing now or Scandinavian countries being mostly streaming based to you downgrading sales for albums released in 2008-2011 when streaming didn’t even exist? Makes no sense. That affects albums released in the last few years, not a decade ago. And yes, it’s funny because you decided to increase other artists’ sales in recent updates instead of downgrading them… It should be the same for everybody, right? I just read in a comment here that you decided to include Ringtones in digital singles… and thus the increases. Why should I complain about… Read more »
You are completely off the mark. It seems you don’t really care about what’s true / real but I’ll still take the time to give you a detailed explanation. My historical formulas were compiled more than a decade ago – I started to study deeply records sales way back in 2003. By then, the market was global with tons of tiny countries doing well. When some relevant market had a notable up / down, I adjusted it, but without going through the market size of all minor countries again and again. While compiling Coldplay’s article, I noticed my estimates were… Read more »
Look, I know you dedicate a lot of time to this and you really love charts. I appreciate it. But you’re not the only one. Many others follow charts as well for years and years. You should really try to not treat everybody who don’t agree with you as “blind fans” or as if they knew nothing about charts. There will be people in here posting things just like “my diva sold more”, that’s for sure… but others just love charts as much as you do and might have different estimations and think your numbers are sometimes not accurate (or… Read more »
Do you know the main difference between me and 99% of people following charts? It is that most people follow one specific artist or at best 2/3, while I follow the entire market. On that situation, you can act 100% objective, you won’t see it all. That’s why you haven’t notice Mexico was including streams for a couple of years, or why you didn’t realize promo singles sales are then excluded from Soundscan when the user buys the album, that’s also why you call “pre-streaming era” albums from 2008-2012 for Scandinavian sales while by the latter date streaming was already… Read more »
he did the same to Katy Perry, Britney, Rihanna, etc. it’s just fair
Mexico (Amprofon) doesn’t include streaming for albums certifications. Just for singles. (Amprofon announced in Dec. 2016 that streaming was now included for singles certifications, they never said anything about albums). Joanne was certified Platinum there three weeks ago (you can check it in Amprofon’s Facebook page) for 60k copies. Even if streaming was included for certifications there (which it isn’t), 20k copies in Mexico (as you posted) would mean 33% of that certification coming from sales and 67% from streaming, which is absurd. Your figures for some European countries are reeeeally low. Same for Million Reasons.. 1.5 million worldwide when… Read more »
Hi Nympho, It isn’t because Amprofon is a mess at communicating updates that you should assume streaming isn’t included. Do you seriously believe that Avicii, who haven’t even chart in the sales ranking, can be certified with pure sales? Of course not. They have been including streaming since 2 years which is why Drake, Weeknd, Calvin Harris, etc. suddenly got tons of Platinum awards. Let’s get real, Post Malone’s Stoney has been certified Plat at the same time as Gaga and his album hasn’t even been released in Mexico. If you doubt that they are a mess at providing accurate… Read more »
thanks for this MJD.
you have a typo with JOANNE’s digital euivalent tho. you have it at 324k.. i think that’s not factoring the 1.5 in your analysis. thanks dear
Hi Frankz / Beysus!
Thanks for noticing, typo fixed!
but you have PI – 450K plus MR – 1.53M plus Other tracks – 1.23M = 3.21M which is equal to 481.5k album equivalent not just 324k.
Thanks.
The Other tracks at 1,23m was from a copy/paste of Artpop, Joanne’s remaining songs did 180k, it is sorted right now!
180k is what A-Yo alone must have sold worldwide.
Canada: 2,300 – 6,000 – 3,000 (11,300)
US: 7,000 – 30,000 – 18,000 (55,000)
France: 350
UK: 8,332
It sold close to 80k in its first weeks in those 4 countries alone (it charted in the main singles charts or the downloads charts of several other countries as well).
180k for all the album remaining tracks worldwide, 1.5 years later it’s not accurate at all.
What about some seriousness rather than blind fanatism while talking about figures, nympho? You perfectly know that A-Yo dropped very fast afterwards, completely disappearing from the US Top 1000 in no time. No doubt you also know that it sold these units while it was a promotional single, meaning all people who then bought the album with the Complete My Album functionality (which basically all fans jumping on promo singles do once the album is available in full) are later excluded from these figures. I’m sure you also know album cuts failed to chart in all relevant DL markets when… Read more »
okay, thanks for the clarification.
Thanks for posting! Would you say Joanne is a comeback era in the same vein as Ray of Light, The Emancipation of Mimi, Circus, etc.? I’ve seen a lot of Gaga fans claim this and I’d like to hear your opinion.
Circus sold less than Beyonce’s 4 which is considered a flop albums. Circus flopped hun. It isn’t even multiplatinum in the states
Hello, Greg. Going by your logic of comparing an album to “4” to know if it flopped: -ANTi by Rihanna, the most successful female release of 2016, flopped, since it did 3M less than “4” -Beyoncé’s own albums released in 2013 and 2016, Sefl-Titled and Lemonade, flopped -Bangerz by Miley Cyrus and Pure Heroin by Lorde flopped -24k Magic by Bruno flopped I hope you realize how absurd it is to claim “Circus” flopped because it did less CSPC than “4”. Both albums ARE successful (4 was saved by its fantastic recurrent streams and sales), but what makes “Circus” the… Read more »
Circus is ok. Not a flop or sucess. Just it did weaker than other releases of the same period. But for example did better than Rated R when Rihanna was on her peak.
Circus wasn’t a TF-sized smash but it’s a certified success. From MJD himself:
“Putting this into her own perspective, this means out of 8 albums there is 2 huge smashes, 3 clear flops, 2 good+ successes (ITZ / Circus) and one good-ok success (Britney), which is definitely an “irregular” trajectory.”
http://chartmasters.org/2017/06/cspc-britney-spears-popularity-analysis-new/
britney was already on her 6th album, Rihanna and Beyoncé at the height of her career, it’s the same as saying that Ray of Light failed, as it sold half of what Britney and Backstreet sold.
Circus’s pure album sales and digital single sales alone put it at 2,750,000 in the US. Once you add streaming, it’s over or at least really close to 3x Platinum.
OT: Wonderful job as usual! 😉
you’re crazy to say that Circus failed
released in December 2008, it was one of the top 10 bestselling albums of 2009, 505k debut in the US, and is already eligible for 3x on the RIAA, but RCA didn’t buy the updates, not to mention that it had 3 big hits, #1 on BB200 #1 on BB hot 100, 2009’s most successful women’s tour in north america….
Joanne is a comeback era in her name and brand. commercially it did well/decent if you consider that the album’s genre ain’t mainstream.
Hi Chrysalynne Lingling!
Joanne did OK, but it was nowhere near a comeback like the ones you mentioned. All of them outperformed their predecessors by 2 to 1 or more, Joanne did much less than Artpop. It did slightly better than C2C, but the same fans argued (correctly) it wasn’t a proper album to explain its low sales, so in order to be consistent in terms of popularity evolution we need to compare Joanne to Artpop and it did definitely worse than this one.
Joanne did ok? Femme Fatale sold double in equivalent sales and you said that it was a flop. Britney fans made pointless accusations. In my opinion, you dont want more hatred from fans of pop divas.
Hi Moore,
Comparing absolute numbers to judge the success of a record is nonsense. The whole notion of success / flop is always relative to expectations. Joanne was the follow up of a major failure, FF followed a great comeback to form, so comparing their raw figures is truly irrelevant.
Joanne’s expectations were also high. It was supposed to be Lady Gaga’s comeback and has it had a very big and ambitious promotion campaign, in addition to many discounts. However, it has only sold 55 percent of what Art Pop sold, which was a flop. On the other hand, Femme Fatale sold 60 percent of what Circus sold, a successful album. Therefore, Femme Fatale’s sales are more impressive than Joanne’s.
Hi Moore,
Expectations aren’t defined by wishes of fans but by investments of majors. Labels always invest their money as per the sales history of an artist: when he comes back from a failure, they will plan limited budgets for their promotional efforts and they will have consistent expectations as per the investments. FF did OK just like Joanne.
Joanne: 2,2m
Witness: 1,9m
One is supposed to be a comeback and the other is supposed to be a bomb. I guess the standards are different.
Witness will easily outsell Joanne in the near future because it has way better streaming…plus the Witness Tour is still going strong therefore the album/singles sales are getting a boost too!
Pure Sales
Joanne – 1.22M
Witness – 600k
CSPC
Prism – 10,571,000
Witness – 1,911,000
Decline: 82%
Artpop – 3,953,000
Joanne -2,253,000
Decline: 43%
Sales
Prism – 4,230,000
Witness – 600,000
Decline: 86%
Artpop – 2,110,000
Joanne -1,330,000
Decline: 47%
Do you really need more explanation as of why Witness is considered such a big flop for Katy?
I’m also assuming you made a typo on page 11 by listing Joanne at 90K units from digital sales, the same you listed C2C as.
What caused the huge boost in Poker Face?
I’m assuming the HUGE ringtones download. he did the same to every songs from other artists.
You inflated these sales to the heavens. Britney is better and sold more. You should do something better with your time and life and not this pointless stuff. We have Billboard for this
Hi Denzel,
What’s pointless is comments like “Britney is better and sold more”. If you had spent more time on Billboard, maybe you would have understood what it is about a bit better. There is no “lies” or whatever, nor the Billboard provides Global figures. Poker Face increased because pre-2010 downloads in SK were estimated rather than let blank, the version LLG vs GLG Radio Mix was added to it (which sold wonders in Japan) and because it out-performed Ringtones averages with over 1,4 million sales in the US.
Hi, MJD
Can you provide the year-end chart of 2010 for downloads in Korea with figures? Gaon website didn’t provide figures. And I wonder if there were still lots of ringtones at that time which were never counted.
They exist in the web archive actually, here you go: https://web.archive.org/web/20110309025548/http://www.gaonchart.co.kr/main/section/notice/view.gaon?idx=39
this is such a childish comment from an OGH I guess? bring this bitterness to SYG
The only pointless thing in here is your idiotic comment.
These numbers are not a value judgement. Anyone can say that their favorite is “better”. This is not about whose music was better. It’s about how much they sold.