Remaining Long Format Part 17 – Box Sets #1
For box sets too there is two kind of packages – extensive compilations with a random assembly of tracks and previously issued albums packaged together.
In the latter case, sales are attributed into each album part of the box set. In a CSPC logic that highlights the dependencies and the cannibalization effect between all products of an artist. It is fundamental to take into account that a consumer of such a career-covering box won’t be buying individual albums anymore. Thus, they all get awarded the sale.
Is Beatles the best selling musical act in UK?
Yes.
I hope you would update and make a record and achievement section for the Beatles
Will BTS surpass the Beatles eventually? And is it possible that a current artist at present will surpass them?
Hi Jeric!
Nobody can predict the future, but considering how strong they keep going and how far ahead they are, it’s very unlikely they will be topped anytime soon, and even less likely by an artist already identified.
Thank you for your response!
Someone shared on Twitter that the Beatles is the second best selling artist of the century. Eminem took the first place. Can you pls confirm this fact? Thanks ahead and more power!
Dont think so. Based on this site Btitney and Coldplay should sold more based on album sales alone. And pretty sure they sold more singles too.
This was discussed like two weeks ago in the “Best selling artists of all time” comments, Britney wouldn’t even be top 10… Coldplay might be #5, and indeed the Beatles would be #2, way behind Eminem.
Jeric, that is true but it needs some clarification. In the USA point of sales are measured by Nielsen SoundCard (now called MRC Nielsen). At the end of 2009 Nielsen estimated that Feminism was the #1 Artist of the first decade of the New Century (32m Album units sold) with The Beatles #2 (30m). Again this constitutes US album sales only from 2000-2009, and did not factor in Digital Downloads, Streaming, Video Streams, etc. Hope this helps.
Oops … sorry @Jericho. “feminism” is supposed to be EMINEM.
@jeric (sorry)
You show the US sales for the White Album at around 12 million. It is a double album. The RIAA has its sales at 24 million plus, making allowance for the fact that it is 2 records that were purchased. Ditto for the red and blue albums. The Anthologies were triple albums, as were the BBC albums.
Do your numbers make allowance for this?
Nope. The White Album, Physical Graffiti, The Wall etc are counted as one album, one sale, no multiplication of discs included, times sales.
One of the albums you mention, is probably the best example against multi counting. The double disc, Red Album, which has less tracks and a shorter total running time, than single disc 1.
I’m not sure I follow. If one buys and pays for an album that contains 2 records, have 2 records not been sold?
Do you allow for this by using the total number of tracks on the album?
Hi Richard! Our goal is not to be mere accountants, but to draw an accurate picture of the artists’ popularity, hence the “Commensurate Sales to Popularity Concept” tag. Would White Album be a much bigger seller if it was a single disc than Abbey Road? The Wall way ahead of Dark Side of the Moon? Physical Graffiti hands down bigger than II? To all these questions, the answer is no. In fact, for 2 of these 3 cases, despite the much longer tracklists, the albums have less streams than single albums they are compared to. This shows that the number… Read more »
MJD:Thank you for expaining that!
I really enjoy and appreciate the work that went into, and still goes into, your website. I look forward to updates as they appear.
Update would be nice 🙂
Hi MJD,
the RIAA certifications on red album and blue album also include download and streaming, seen how much higher are they ?
I’ve just realized that the physical single sales of Beatles For Sale and A Hard Day’s Night are swapped.
I think this should get an update. It’s been 3 years and a lot of things have happened like the anniversary editions of Abbey Road and the White Album. (Also pls do George and Ringo’s CSPC 🙂 )
I’m positive they’ll be well above 420 mill after the update.
Beatles featuring Tony Sheridan is included in the compilation section on page 46
Amazing work, congratulations! However you’ve missed one important EP release. The Beatles fifth Ep release, Long Tall Sally, which was released in Britain in June 1964 and is another reported global million seller.
Has this already been included in the analysis? If not, I hope Chartmasters would consider verifying this one and include its sales in computing the Beatles CSPC points