Destroying Myths: Fake 10 million sellers

Mariah Carey – The Emancipation Of Mimi (2005)

Claimed Sales – 12,000,000
Estimated Sales – 9,100,000

She did it! Mariah Carey gets a third – and this time last – entry among this club of non-10 million selling albums which are claimed as such.

This one was very quickly claimed as being over 10 million, as early as in late 2005 when it closed the year as the top selling album in the US with nearly 5 million scanned sales.

Worldwide, the album was the runner up to the Coldplay set X&Y, selling 7,7 million units. While The Emancipation Of Mimi was still in the Top 10 at the end of 2005 in the US and at the beginning of 2006, it is almost what prevents it from being a 10 million seller. Indeed, the album had a last whisper in early 2006 when it sat for two months inside the Top 20, but it was selling all the copies shipped in excess during the past Christmas season. Then when additional shipments would have been needed again, the album collapsed from #7 to #84 within two months.

The 1,05 million copies sold in the US from 2006 to date requested at most some 700,000 copies shipped. With 7,7 million copies sold during 2005 and such a weak number since in the country representing more than two thirds of its total sales, the 10 million barrier is still far away.

3.1 17 votes
Article Rating
Notify of

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

But the “A Star Is Born Soundtrack” CSPC analysis in this very site, the album has 15 million equivalent sales. Did she reach this ammount of sales in a short period of time since this has been posted, or are you talking about original sales?


how is it that Mariah’s figures on here are higher than what is on her Popularity Analysis article?


“Divas group” comments aside, how did you determine that ‘Invincible’ only sold 7.4 million instead of 10 million? I don’t see your sources or screenshots in the written piece of the article. I’m genuinely curious.

May Holland

Youre questioning MJs popularity? When he sold 50 concerts in 4 hours in LONDON when he was 50 years old… MJ didn’t like touring and rejected to do so for the album. In retaliation Sony cut funding and promotion. As we know now, MJ want cut out for touring at an old age. It was too much for him. Although he probably could’ve got away with doing one or two shows here and there..


What does any of this have to do with Invincible’s sales?

Last edited 1 year ago by Al
Jarrad Hurley

Invincible started out as one of Michael’s fasted-ever selling albums but Sony cut all promotion for it within three months of release and defunded Michael’s planned film clips. It’s unfair to call the album a flop when you consider how well it did in the period when it was actually active – And it did that on the power of only one song that was promoted. I am not going to say Invincible was an incredible album (it wasn’t). But the album had a lot more potential than it showed and Sony didn’t allow it to find its feet. Certainly… Read more »

Pat Smith

Both Sony and Michael Jackson cut all promotion. Michael Jackson refused to perform Invincible songs when he had opportunities to do it. Instead, he decided to perform old stuff like Dangerous (2002) or Man In The Mirror (2001). That’s a strange way to promote his new album… He could have made more sales if he had just decided to perform his new songs. Michael Jackson also refused to get involved in his own video for “Cry”. How can he expect that the album Invincible will get some hype with such a bland video? That tends to show that he was… Read more »


Sorry but was Sony that refused to authorize MJ to perform the new songs. Always Sony decided to stop all kind of promotion ( including cutting short the budget for the Cry video and that’s why M Wasn’t in it ). In a radio interview before the release of the album MJ said clearly that he had planned to do a video for Umbrekable, the lost children and whatever happens at least and after that other kinds of promotions, maybe also a tour. He worked really long and hard as always on this record and had no reason at all… Read more »


Question is which of these albums held up & still sound fresh? Imo Invincible sounds better as time goes on

Would love your thoughts, please comment.x