Streaming World: Beatles results analysis

tHE bEATLES VS MICHAEL JACKSON

Michael Jackson. The Beatles. Varkala Beach.

Below is the Top 20 Songs ranking and Top 10 Albums ranking of both artists merged. As previously mentioned, to get a relevant comparison figures represent the new streams received between March 9 to April 9.

As you may have noted, songs by the Jackson 5 / the Jacksons are included, while songs by John Lennon, Paul McCartney, George Harrison or Ringo Starr are not. This may seem an unfair ruling but it is implied by Spotify work process. In fact, if you join the Beatles page and play their songs in random mode, only the Beatles songs are streamed. In the other side, doing the same on Michael Jackson page will air hits of the Jackson 5 / the Jacksons because of their shared compilations like 2005 set The Essential. As the majority of Spotify users are free users, they only access the random mode, thus making this technicality a key element. In any case, no song from Beatles solo careers would be featured on below Top 20.

Most Popular Songs

01 Michael Jackson Billie Jean – 5 832 000
02 Jackson 5 I Want You Back – 4 517 000
03 The Beatles Here Comes The Sun – 4 156 000
04 Michael Jackson Love Never Felt So Good – 4 008 000
05 Michael Jackson Beat It – 3 640 000
06 The Beatles Let It Be – 3 211 000
07 The Beatles Yesterday – 3 009 000
08 The Beatles Come Together – 2 912 000
09 Jackson 5 ABC – 2 762 000
10 The Beatles Hey Jude – 2 631 000
11 Michael Jackson The Way You Make Me Feel – 2 390 000
12 Michael Jackson Man In The Mirror – 2 227 000
13 Michael Jackson Black Or White – 2 091 000
14 Michael Jackson P.Y.T. – 2 069 000
15 The Beatles I Want To Hold Your Hand – 1 989 000
16 The Beatles Love Me Do – 1 935 000
17 Michael Jackson Thriller – 1 922 000
18 The Beatles Blackbird – 1 857 000
19 The Beatles In My Life – 1 843 000
20 Michael Jackson Don’t Stop Til’ You Get Enough – 1 764 000

The fight is rather close with Michael Jackson owning 11 tracks against 9 for the Beatles. The English band only owns Here Comes The Sun as part of the Top 5 yet. Billie Jean is the predictable winner with a comfortable margin. Results of I Want You Back are kinda outstanding and someway surprising yet. Some 18 months ago, while the track was already among the Top 10 catalog hits from the 60s, it was at the bottom of Michael Jackson own Top 10. Its inclusion in Guardians Of Galaxy soundtrack and Nutella TV ad increased its profile. This is a track of interest for the Beatles fans as the 1969 teen pop smash is fighting with Van Morrison classic song Brown Eyed Girl to get the crown as the 60s biggest hit. Thus, if the Beatles and more precisely Here Comes The Sun are targeting this position, I Want You Back is the song to beat.

Clearly, both of those legendary acts haven’t only released 20 songs together. Following page will focus on the Top 10 Albums.

4 thoughts on “Streaming World: Beatles results analysis”

  1. Very interesting comparison, I was waiting for something like this, as these two acts -along with Elvis Presley- are considered to be the biggest ever. So while The Beatles have sold far more albums than Michael Jackson, at least on Spotify/YouTube there isn’t such a gap (far from that). I remember you made a point about how these new platforms are a better reflection, a purer way of calculating, popularity and comparing acts from different eras. I didn’t get it at first, but now I’m starting to accept it that way.

    You mentioned that The Beatles are “ahead of all other classic bands by a mile”. But are you sure that they top Queen by such a huge margin? At least on YouTube, Queen are ahead of The Beatles and I doubt The Beatles outstream Queen by a big difference difference considering Queen’s strong monthly totals.

    1. Hehe Hernán I was sure you were going to point out this last comment 😉

      It really is on the context of the “arrival […] on streaming platforms”, those 94 million Spotify plays within’ a month put them 48% ahead of Michael Jackson and with likely almost twice as much as Queen (I haven’t audit in details their streams recently). Obviously, watching running time and considering Youtube views but Queen on a much more favorable position compared to the Beatles, although the likes Rolling Stones, Pink Floyd or Led Zeppelin do not face them as well as Queen.

      I’ll be doing the same kind of articles for various artists, Queen will be one of those coming soon 🙂

  2. I checked Queen’s streams yesterday and the total adds up to 1,179 million, compared to 1,013 by 27 December 2015. A jump of 166 million in about 3,5 months, but without counting 4 solo tracks included on Greatest Hits III, which would take the total to 170 million during the same time frame if included.

    That is an average of 48,5 million per month for Queen. Probably over 50 million (considering Spotify is getting bigger every month) in the 31 days considered above.

    So the total is below that of The Beatles (94 million) and Michael Jackson (63 million).

    According to MJD’s numbers, Michael Jackson was on 1,115 by April 2015 and 1,803 now, which is about 688 million in almost one year; whilst Queen were on 595 million in April 2015 and 1,191 million now (including the 4 solo tracks mentioned above), which is 596 million in almost one year. About 688 million against 596 million in 12 months. Not as big a gap as I was assuming.

    As explained, we will have to wait and see what is the real average total for The Beatles, but their numbers look impressive no matter what. That said, The Beatles sold twice as many albums and records as Queen, but Spotify proves that they aren’t necessarily twice as big as Queen because of that.

  3. Thanks for the response, Guillaume. I posted my above comment (with the stream totals for Queen) at the same time as you posted yours, haha.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *